UPDATE ON RASMEA ODEH TRIAL
Friday, November 7 (Day 4 of Trial)
The trial against Palestinian-American Rasmea Odeh began earlier this week in Detroit. Rasmea is being represented by Michael Deutsch of People’s Law Office, with co-counsel Jim Fennerty, another Chicago-based civil rights attorney, along with William Goodman and Dennis Cunningham.
Rasmea is on trial in Federal Court for failing to disclose a prior conviction in her immigration application to the United States. The prior conviction was from Israel and related to a 1969 bombing at a supermarket in Jerusalem. She had been arrested, interrogated and tortured by the Israeli military. As a result of the torture, she confessed to involvement with the bombing.
Prior to trial, the judge made rulings limiting the defense. One of the most significant rulings was prevented Rasmea or her attorneys from raising the torture she suffered or the psychological impact it had on her, which could explain her answers on the immigration form. This was despite the judge finding her torture claims “credible.”
Trial began on Tuesday and the first day was spent selecting a jury. Opening statements took place on Wednesday. Arguing for the government, Assistant US Attorney Mark Jebson argued simply that Rasmea should be convicted for immigration fraud for failing to disclose her 1970 conviction.
During his opening argument, Michael Deutsch detailed Rasmea’s life. He described how she lost the family home to Israeli settlers at a young age and explained how she was arrested and interrogated for weeks by the Israeli military. Due to the judge’s ruling, he was unable to go into detail about the torture she suffered. Deutsch also told the jury about Rasmea’s life here in the United States and how much respect she has in the community. Deutsch closed by asking the jurors to remain fair and use their sense of justice to find Rasmea Not Guilty.
The prosecution presented their case Wednesday afternoon, calling agents from Department of Homeland Security and US Citizenship and Immigration Service. The government’s case continued into Thursday morning.
On Thursday, the defense began presenting their case, calling UIC professor Nadine Naber to describe Rasmea and her work with Muslim and Arab women immigrants in the Chicago area. Following Naber’s testimony, Rasmea took the stand. Rasmea’s testimony went into her life growing up in Palestine where the family was forced from their home in 1948. The family was forced to live as refugees before moving to Ramallah, where they lived during the 1967 war and occupation of the West Bank, Jerusalem and Gaza. Ramsea then described her arrest by the Israeli military, her time as a political prisoner in Israel and her release as part of a prisoner trade.
Rasmea then went on to testify about the immigration process of coming to the United States. She explained her English was weak at the time and she had her brother assist in filling out the forms. She also testified that when there were questions about whether she had been arrested, her understanding was that those questions referred to arrests in the United States.
Rasmea’s testimony will continue today and she will be cross-examined by the government. It is expected that closing arguments will follow her testimony and that the jury will begin deliberating on Monday, November 10.
For more on the trial
Earlier post from our site: Rasmea Odeh Trial to Begin Tuesday
Will Rasmea Odeh Go to Prison Because of a Confession Obtained Through Torture? in The Nation
Report on Rasmea Trial Day 2 by US Palestinian Community Network (USPCN)
Report on Rasmea Trial Day 3 by USPCN
Rasmea Odeh takes the stand in her own defense in Electronic Intifada
Press Release on Tuesday, November 4 from National Lawyers Guild